Skip to the reporting
My account Sign in Subscribe
You have used your free articles this month Subscribe now
← Cyber SECURTY
Cyber SECURTY Cyber SECURTY

Biometrics watchdog backs facial recognition law but says the key safeguards are still undefined

Professor William Webster supports the government’s plan for a single regulator, but says it has not yet said what powers, resources or enforcement reach the regulator will have.…

By Zack Hill November 17, 2026 · 4 min read
Share Share on X Share on LinkedIn Share on Facebook Share on WhatsApp Email this
Image source: University of Stirling

Professor William Webster supports the government’s plan for a single regulator, but says it has not yet said what powers, resources or enforcement reach the regulator will have.

The government’s independent biometrics commissioner has backed its plan to put police use of facial recognition on a statutory footing. He also warns that the proposals leave open the questions that will decide whether they work. In a statement published on 17 November, Professor William Webster, the Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner, said the government’s consultation response “lacks detail in a number of key areas”. Those gaps range from what will be written into primary legislation to whether a new oversight body will have enough resources.

His view carries weight because his own office is one of the functions the new regulator is meant to take over. The new body will consolidate and expand existing oversight functions, taking account of the Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner and the Forensic Science Regulator. Police use of the technology is also growing faster than the law governing it is being written. The Home Office cited 2,631 Metropolitan Police arrests following live deployments between January 2025 and October 2026. The Met plans to extend static cameras to the West End and Soho in December.

The Home Office published its plans on 4 November. They include a specific law requiring deployments to be “intelligence led and proportionate”, independent bias testing of police technology for age, gender and race, and a statutory code of practice, drafted with a new regulator, binding every force. The regulator could seek court injunctions against forces in extreme cases. The framework will set a minimum rank for officers who can authorise use, but the rank has not been specified. Presenting the plans, the Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, called the technology “the biggest breakthrough for catching criminals since DNA matching.”

Webster takes a more cautious view of the technology itself. Biometric surveillance tools, he wrote, “are intrusive and conflict directly with fundamental human rights”, including privacy, freedom of expression and peaceful assembly. He welcomed the commitment that the new body will have compliance powers. He also welcomed the plan to extend the framework beyond policing to other public services, with a separate code for the commercial sector. That code would cover retailers using facial recognition against shoplifting. Facewatch CEO Nick Fisher welcomed the plan, saying the government should “set a high bar” for every provider, including Facewatch.

The commissioner’s list of unanswered questions is long. It is not yet clear how necessity and proportionality will be measured, who will judge whether individual applications are effective and acceptable, how national technical and operational standards will be developed, or how compliance will be enforced in the private sector. He said the new body’s resources and specialist expertise must match its responsibilities, and that coordination with other regulators would be “essential to avoid duplication and gaps in oversight”. That concern has a concrete basis: the response doesn’t explain how the new body and the ICO would divide responsibilities, even though the Information Commissioner’s Office already regulates police processing of personal data.

Analysts reading the document have pointed to other gaps. It does not commit on whether facial recognition can be banned at protests, retention periods for facial images, specific protections for children, or its reach into Scotland and Northern Ireland. No legislative text, timetable, or impact assessment was published.

Webster also pointed to uneven practice across the country. “Recent live facial recognition deployments I have observed show differences in practice between police forces,” he wrote. He argued that the new regime should build on the existing Surveillance Camera Code of Practice and the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012, and that a single regulator should help simplify what he called a “cluttered regulatory landscape”. He also expects the technology to move into body-worn video and drones, and said Parliament’s ability to add new technologies to the framework later was essential.

The proposals follow a long run-up. The Home Office ran its consultation from 4 December 2025 until 12 February 2026. Before it closed, the government had already committed to expanding the technology. The Home Office pledged to fund 40 new LFR vans as part of a national program to expand facial recognition capabilities in town centres across England and Wales, in a January policing white paper. Civil liberties groups remain divided on the new plans. Big Brother Watch said the technology treats everyone who walks by as a suspect by default. Liberty director Akiko Hart called the announcement a step in the right direction but urged ministers to pause the rapid rollout of the technology until safeguards are in place.

Webster has also said he was left out of related decisions. He told Liberty Investigates he wasn’t consulted on the Home Office’s immigration enforcement plans for live facial recognition, which he said fall outside his remit.

The measures are due to be included in the Police Reform Bill. The bill will be introduced to Parliament “in due course,” with no specific date given. Webster called the legislation “a once in a generation opportunity” and said there was “an urgent need” for it, because facial recognition is “diffusing into society rapidly”. The detail he is asking for will only become available once the bill’s text is published.

 

The Daily Briefing
One email, 7am, the six things that moved

Written by the newsroom, not a summariser. Free, and you can leave whenever.

0 comments

Anyone can read the thread · subscribers can post
Subscriber conversation Read the thread below as long as you like. Posting is open to subscribers, which is why it reads like a newsroom and not a comment section. Join the conversation Sign in
Sponsored Paid for by the advertiser. The newsroom had no part in it.

More on this topic

All Cyber SECURTY →